Back to homepage

States reach $183.5M multistate settlement with rent-to-own provider over alleged pricing, disclosure, and servicing practices

November 20, 2026

On November 12, a coalition of 43 state attorneys general, led by an 11-state executive committee, announced a $183.5 million settlement with a rent-to-own finance company and its parent (see, e.g., Colorado’s press release here and consent judgment here). The CFPB sued the company in 2024 (covered by InfoBytes here) and voluntarily dismissed the action with prejudice in March 2025 (covered here). The states alleged that the company marketed its rental-purchase agreements (RPAs) as 90-day payoff programs without adequately disclosing that consumers were automatically placed into the maximum term, often 12 months, and could pay about twice the advertised cash price. They also alleged that the company described RPAs in terms suggesting traditional credit, obscured contract terms during e-signing, marked up merchandise prices, impeded terminations, and engaged in deceptive servicing, collection, and credit reporting practices.

Without admitting liability and while denying wrongdoing, the company agreed to pay $43 million in restitution and $10.5 million to the states, and to reduce to zero the balances of certain charged-off accounts, totaling $130 million, with consumers keeping the merchandise and the company requesting removal of the associated tradelines. The consent judgments also, among other things: (i) bar “same as cash” and similar advertising (except for early purchase options priced at or below the cash price), cash-price markups, and representations that RPAs are loans or do not create debt; (ii) require more prominent total-cost disclosures and presentation of the RPA before e-signing; (iii) bar obstructing terminations and threatening repossession or court action the company does not intend to take; (iv) prohibit reporting new RPAs to the three nationwide consumer reporting agencies for five years; and (v) require retailer training and three annual compliance reports to the executive committee.