NYC Council bill would allow city to take action against unconscionable practices without prior rulemaking
On November 12, New York City Council Member Chi Ossé introduced the Unconscionable Consumer Abuse Prevention (UNCAP) Act (Int. 1168-2026). The bill would amend the city’s Consumer Protection Law (CPL) so that the New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) could take enforcement action against “unconscionable” trade practices without a local law or rule first declaring the specific practice unconscionable and describing it “with reasonable particularity.” Ossé and DCWP Commissioner Samuel A.A. Levine announced the bill on November 13. The bill would also revise the CPL’s definition of an unconscionable trade practice to cover any act or practice “in the conduct of any business, trade or commerce.” The definition already expressly covers the extension of consumer credit and the collection of consumer debts, and reaches acts or practices that unfairly take advantage of a consumer’s lack of knowledge, ability, experience, or capacity, or that result in a gross disparity between the value received by a consumer and the price paid.
In addition, the bill lists six factors to consider in determining whether a practice is unconscionable. The factors are: (i) merchants’ knowledge that consumers are unable to receive “properly anticipated benefits” from the goods or services involved; (ii) a gross disparity between price and value, measured by the price at which other consumers readily obtain similar goods or services; (iii) whether a practice may enable merchants to take advantage of consumers’ inability to reasonably protect their interests because of physical or mental infirmities, illiteracy, inability to understand the language of the agreement, ignorance or lack of education, or similar factors; (iv) the degree to which the terms of the transaction require consumers to waive legal rights; (v) the degree to which the terms require consumers to jeopardize money or property beyond what is immediately at issue in the transaction; and (vi) definitions of unconscionability in statutes, regulations, rulings, and decisions of legislative or judicial bodies in New York or elsewhere.
The bill would also add to the definition of a deceptive trade practice any conduct that would violate New York General Business Law sections 349 or 350, authorize the city to bring a special proceeding in the New York State Supreme Court, and permit enforcement regardless of whether the act or practice is consumer oriented. The bill would take effect immediately, though, according to the Council’s plain-language summary, it would not affect actions or proceedings pending on its effective date. The bill would further extend the CPL’s violation-counting provisions to unconscionable trade practices, so that each deceptive or unconscionable statement, description, representation, or omission would be a distinct and independent violation, with additional counting rules for repeated public exposures. Alternatively, if DCWP showed the number of consumers reached and that the person knew or should have known the conduct was deceptive or unconscionable, the penalty would be based on each consumer reached.