Eleventh Circuit affirms summary judgment upholding CFPB’s PACE rule
On November 13, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit affirmed a district court’s grant of summary judgment to the CFPB, rejecting a trade organization’s challenge to the Bureau’s Residential Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Financing rule under the APA. The rule, as previously covered by InfoBytes, clarifies that Regulation Z’s exclusion of tax liens and assessments from the definition of credit applies only to involuntary ones, bringing PACE financing under TILA, including its ability-to-repay and integrated TILA-RESPA disclosure requirements. The rule also extends TILA civil liability to private PACE companies “substantially involved” in the credit decision. The trade organization challenged the rule in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in May 2025, and the court denied its motion for a preliminary injunction in November 2025 before upholding the rule in February.
The panel held that PACE loans are consumer credit transactions under TILA, and therefore the PACE Financing rule fell within the Bureau’s general rulemaking authority. It rejected the argument that the loans are not credit under TILA because the obligations run with the property, citing TILA’s coverage of nonrecourse reverse mortgages and language in at least some program contracts in which property owners acknowledge responsibility for paying the assessments. The court also rejected the argument that this reading renders section 307 of the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act superfluous, and found that the Bureau reasonably accounted for the “unique nature” of PACE financing, as that provision requires.
The court likewise rejected the trade organization’s argument that the rule is arbitrary and capricious. It held that, even assuming the Bureau relied on its 2023 PACE report, the organization’s objections to the report’s methodology did not show that the rule was unreasonable or inadequately explained. On the organization’s claim that the rule violates the Tenth Amendment, the court reasoned that PACE programs “facilitate debts, not taxes,” that the rule regulates the financing rather than tax collection, and that it applies evenhandedly whether a local government or a private company operates a program.