District court rejects lack of notice defense to RESPA escrow claim, sides with servicer on contract claim
On November 17, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Alabama issued an order denying a mortgage servicer’s motion for summary judgment on a borrower’s RESPA claims but granting it on the borrower’s breach of contract claim. According to the order, after servicing of the borrower’s loan was transferred to the servicer, the servicer did not pay the renewal premium on her escrowed homeowners’ insurance policy. The insurer canceled the policy, and it lapsed permanently when the servicer did not pay before the reinstatement deadline. The servicer asserted that the data it received from the prior servicer did not identify the policy, its renewal dates, or that a renewal premium was due. The borrower had received the insurer’s premium-due, renewal-reminder, and cancellation notices but did not forward them to the servicer, and she later sent the servicer a notice of error regarding the unpaid premium.
The court held that a servicer’s duty under 12 U.S.C. § 2605(g) to pay escrowed premiums on time is not conditioned on notice that a premium is due but arises when the loan is a “federally related mortgage loan” and its terms require escrow payments. Finding no support in the statute text or case law for an exception for servicers that lack actual knowledge of due dates, the court concluded that the law makes “no notice-based exceptions” to that duty. It also found fact issues existed on the borrower’s notice-of-error claims, including whether the servicer, which asserted that it had investigated and determined that no error occurred, provided a response to the borrower that complied with Regulation X, and whether its investigation was reasonable. The court observed that a jury finding that the servicer erred in failing to pay could also find that an investigation that failed to uncover that error was not reasonable. On the contract claim, however, the court noted that the mortgage required the borrower to “furnish to Lender all notices or invoices of amounts to be paid,” and concluded that because she never forwarded the insurer’s notices, she had not substantially performed and could not enforce the mortgage against the servicer.